I believe she'd turn Indian giver and take back her gift to Overton.

He gave them to you and he's not an Indian giver.

I'd be mightily hurt and shocked to find out that you were an Indian giver.

Nature seems to have been like an Indian giver, taking away the gifts as soon as they are received,-

They're Indian givers, they are.

Perhaps the most humiliating moment of Dulcie Cowan's childhood had been when Mary Dean had called her Indian giver.

"The last thing they'd want to be accused of is being a bunch of Indian givers."

"Take your scarf pin, Indian giver," jeered Hippy, holding out a small package, then jerking it back again.

"Are you an Indian giver?"